← All titles
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
TV series · 2022Action & AdventureSci-Fi & FantasyDrama

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

Evil has had many names.

60Mixed

AI Woke Score

Mixed

Noticeable identity content woven in.

confidence: high

no votes yet

Audience Score

Be the first to vote.

Where to watch

Amazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime Video with Ads

The Verdict

Rings of Power leans into diversified casting across Tolkien's races and builds its narrative around an idealized, often-vindicated Galadriel while diminishing several male leaders. There's no notable LGBTQ+ content, and preachiness is moderate. (spoiler) The biggest controversy is structural: heavy compression of the Second Age timeline and invented arcs that stray from Tolkien's writings.

What the AI Flagged

Each axis scored 0–100, with the receipts. The headline score weights the worst offense, so a single egregious element isn't diluted by the rest.

Identity Swaps

45

Tolkien's elves, dwarves, and Harfoots are depicted with diverse casting not specified in the source, drawing attention as deliberate changes.

  • Arondir, a black Silvan elf
  • Princess Disa, a black dwarf
  • Diverse Harfoot community

Girlboss & Male Demotion

70

Galadriel is written as a near-infallible warrior whose judgment is consistently vindicated while male leaders (Elrond, Gil-galad, Numenoreans) are shown as wrong or obstructive.

  • Galadriel out-fighting and lecturing male soldiers
  • Galadriel repeatedly proven right against male counsel
  • Galadriel physically dominant in combat scenes

LGBTQ+ / Trans / Non-Binary Content

10

No prominent LGBTQ+, trans, or non-binary characters or storylines are featured in the series.

DEI Casting

55

Casting diversifies traditionally homogenous Tolkien races in a way that reads as a deliberate inclusion choice rather than lore-driven.

  • Multi-ethnic elves and dwarves
  • Diverse Harfoots and Numenoreans

Preachiness

25

Some dialogue carries modern thematic notes about belonging and prejudice, but the show is not heavily sermonizing.

  • Arondir/Bronwyn cross-species romance framed against bigotry
  • Themes of outsiders being judged

Anti-Masculinity / Anti-West

30

Several male authority figures are framed as fearful, foolish, or obstructive contrasted with the heroic female lead, though not an explicit thesis.

  • Numenorean leaders portrayed as cowardly or shortsighted
  • Male elves underestimating Galadriel

Source Betrayal

75

The series compresses thousands of years of Second Age timeline and invents characters and arcs, departing substantially from Tolkien's appendices.

  • Compressed timeline of the Second Age
  • Invented romances and characters
  • Mystery-box reworking of Sauron and the rings' origins

Trailer & Photos

Audience Reviews

Discussion

Cast & Crew

Justin Doble (Executive Producer) · John D. Payne (Executive Producer) · Patrick McKay (Executive Producer) · Callum Greene (Executive Producer)

More on the board